← All Lessons

Questions on the Classic Readings

William Shakespeare, “Sonnet 73”

  1. The sonnet gives three pictures of the speaker’s age: a season, the end of a day and a dying fire. In what order do they come, and how does each change the sense of time left?
  2. Why might “Bare ruin'd choirs, where late the sweet birds sang” be stronger than a plain statement that the speaker is old?

Langston Hughes, “Mother to Son”

  1. The mother says, “Life for me ain’t been no crystal stair.” What does her stair have instead?
  2. How does the metaphor become advice by the end of the poem?

A metaphor says that one thing is another and asks the reader to see both at once. Shakespeare sets three metaphors for age side by side; Hughes keeps a single one, a staircase, from the first line to the last. The example below draws its metaphors from the speaker’s own work as a teacher of English.

The classic readings come first, and they are the heart of the lesson. A poem by James Mulhern follows as a working example, for a practical reason: he can tell a class what he was trying to do in it, and where he is still unsure he managed it.

The complete poemas published in Crossings

“Longing”

Colleagues ask for my criteria

when grading English papers.

Family members want the meanings

of mystifying words.

Students praise my speaking skills

and assume I am smart.

My erudition impresses them—

then they walk away.

Nights, I scour Shakespeare,

wander the web,

lauding lines of literature,

commending clever craft—

focused yet saddened,

longing to be liked,

to feel significant to someone,

distinct like a Dickinson dash.

Mostly,

I feel small—

a tiny font,

the blank space beyond a colon,

an abandoned thought.

A letter lacking closure,

or a line—

stranded and incomplete.

Preceding naught.

From Crossings.

The poem begins plainly, with colleagues, family and students, and saves its metaphors for the end. When the speaker feels small, he describes himself in the terms of his trade: a tiny font, the blank space beyond a colon, a letter lacking closure, a line left incomplete. The hope was that these figures would feel earned because they come from the speaker’s working life, and that the last line, “Preceding naught,” would act like a colon with nothing after it.

A suggestion. If a poem of yours names a feeling directly, you might try describing it in the terms of something you know well, such as your work, a craft or a place, and see whether a metaphor from that world says it more exactly.

Questions on James Mulhern’s Example

“Longing”

  1. The first two stanzas contain almost no metaphor. Why might the poem save its metaphors for the end?
  2. Where do the metaphors in the last two stanzas come from, and why does that source matter?
  3. “The blank space beyond a colon” and “Preceding naught” both describe something that points forward to nothing. What do they suggest about the speaker?

Activities

These draw on the classic readings and on the example on this page.

  1. Three metaphors. On the model of Sonnet 73, write three metaphors for one feeling or stage of life, arranged so that each narrows or deepens the one before.
  2. From your own world. Write a short poem in which a feeling is described entirely in the terms of your work, a hobby or a place you know well. Begin plainly and let the metaphor arrive.

—Silver Current Press

Silver Current Press family: Silver Current Press · The 2601 Salon · For Program Partners · Mulhern Teaches English · The Gathering Room →