← All Lessons

Questions on the Classic Readings

W. W. Jacobs, “The Monkey’s Paw”

  1. The sergeant-major says the fakir “wanted to show that fate ruled people’s lives, and that those who interfered with it did so to their sorrow.” How does that line set up the plot?
  2. Mr. White wishes for two hundred pounds. How does the money arrive, and why is that plot so effective?

Guy de Maupassant, “The Necklace”

  1. Trace the chain of events from the invitation to the end. Which single choice causes most of what follows?
  2. In the last line Madame Forestier says, “Why, my necklace was paste! It was worth at most only five hundred francs!” Why does this change our view of everything before it?

A plot is a chain of causes. One choice leads to a consequence, which forces another choice, until the story has nowhere else to go. Jacobs builds his plot on three wishes; Maupassant builds his on one borrowed necklace and a decision to hide its loss. The example below, from the middle of a story, follows a grandmother’s schemes as each one leads to the next.

The classic readings come first, and they are the heart of the lesson. A passage from a story by James Mulhern follows as a working example, for a practical reason: he can tell a class what he was trying to do in it, and where he is still unsure he managed it.

Aiden lives with his grandmother, Nanna, while his mother is in a psychiatric hospital. Nanna is broke. Over one long day she visits friends and plans to take a gold chalice from a healing service at Mission Church, hoping it might cure her daughter. In this passage, at her friend Margie’s house, she has just sent Aiden upstairs, where he has filled his pockets with Margie’s jewelry.

A page from the story · the middle

My grandmother smiled at me. “Of course there are miracles today. As a matter of fact, I’m taking Aiden to a priest at Mission church. A charismatic healer is what they call him. Aiden’s going to be cured, aren’t you, honey?”

“Cured of what?” Margie said.

“He’s got a little something wrong with his blood is all. Too many white cells. Leukemia. But this priest will take care of it.”

“Leukemia!” Margie said. “Catherine, that’s serious.” Margie tried to smile at me, but I could tell she was upset. “Sit down, honey.” She motioned for me to go to the table. “We’re almost done here.”

“You gotta take him to a good doctor,” she whispered to my grandmother, as if I couldn’t hear.

“I know that. I’m not dumb. God will take care of everything.”

We said our goodbyes. In the car, my grandmother announced, “Let me see what you got.” I pulled the goods out of my pockets while she unclasped her black plastic pocketbook. Her eyes lit up.

“Perfect. She isn’t looking, is she?” I peered at the house. Margie was nowhere in sight. Probably sitting on her rocking chair with Arnold in her lap.

“Put those in here.” She nodded towards her bag.

When we were about to turn onto Tremont Street where the church was, I remembered the gold necklace and cross. I pulled it out of my pocket. My grandmother took it from me, running a red light. “This would look beautiful on Laura.” In a moment, a policeman pulled us over.

“Don’t say anything,” my grandmother said. We moved to the side of the road. She looked in the rearview mirror and rolled her window down.

“Ma’am, you just ran a red light.” He was tall with a hooked nose and dark brown close-set eyes.

“I know, officer. I was saying a prayer with my grandson. He gave me this gold cross and I got distracted. I’m very sorry.”

He leaned into the car. I smiled.

“Is that a birthday gift for your grandmother?”

“Yes. I wanted to surprise her.”

“And he certainly did.” She patted my knee and smiled at the police officer.

“It’s a good thing no cars were coming. You could have been hurt,” he said. “That’s a beautiful cross,” he added.

My grandmother began to cry. “Isn’t it though?” She sniffled.

The officer placed his hand firmly on the edge of the window. “Consider this a warning. You can go but I’d put that cross away.”

“Of course. Of course.” She turned to me. “Here, Aiden. Put it back in your pocket.”

The policeman waited for us to drive away. I turned and looked. He waved.

“Are you sad, Nanna?”

“Don’t be silly.” She waved her hand. “That was an act.”

I laughed and she did, too.

From The Weight of Small Mercies.

Each step in the passage is caused by the one before it. A lie about the visit to Mission Church, that Aiden has leukemia, wins Margie’s sympathy. The jewelry in Aiden’s pockets distracts Nanna at a red light, and the gold cross becomes a story for the police officer. Nanna’s tears, which she calls “an act,” prepare for the moment near the end of the story when her tears are real. The aim was a chain the reader can follow, in which each complication grows out of a choice.

A suggestion. If the events in your draft could happen in any order, you might try linking them so that each scene happens because of a choice made in the scene before.

Questions on James Mulhern’s Example

“Keep Calm and Carry On”

  1. Nanna tells Margie that Aiden has leukemia. What does that lie cause, in this passage and later in the day?
  2. Why does Nanna run the red light, and how does she turn the problem to her advantage?
  3. Nanna says her tears were “an act.” How does this moment prepare for the end of the story?

Activities

These draw on the classic readings and on the example on this page.

  1. Because, not and then. Outline a story in six sentences, each beginning “Because of that.”
  2. A choice with a cost. Write a scene in which a character makes one small choice that leads, in a later scene, to a consequence the character did not foresee.

—Silver Current Press

Silver Current Press family: Silver Current Press · The 2601 Salon · For Program Partners · Mulhern Teaches English · The Gathering Room →