A Note for Readers, Before You Begin

This essay moves through poems from an earlier, expanded manuscript of Crossings. The published book—Crossings: Selected Poems (Silver Current Press, August 2026)—is a tighter, twenty-poem selection. It opens with “A Prayer” and closes with “Leaves,” not with “Copacetic” and “Moving Forward” as the discussion below might suggest; both appear in the book, but not first and last. Four poems discussed here—“Longing,” “The Guard,” “To Be,” “Simply Silly”—are not in the published edition. The rest of the essay’s references—“Water,” “Copacetic,” “Dark City,” “The Crosswalk,” “Carol”—are. I chose the smaller sequence because it read as the more cohesive book. The remaining poems live in full on the Complete Collection page, and some are bound for a forthcoming, enlarged, illustrated edition of Crossings (date to be determined), where I mean to give myself more room.

I offer that multiplicity of versions not as inconsistency but as faith. A poem revised is a small resurrection—the same material returning transfigured, never finished because it is still becoming. Emerson said as much in “Circles”: people wish to be settled, and only so far as they remain unsettled is there any hope for them. Hope, I’ve come to believe, needs that unsettledness the way a life needs breath.

This is close to why I teach. A student arrives unsettled, too—not yet the person they will become. Helping one discover the gifts already there feels less like instruction than like grace. It is, simply, a blessing. Shirley Chisholm called service the rent we pay for the privilege of living on this earth. Part of that rent, I think, is homage—to the thinkers and the kindness that shaped us, Emerson among mine. Elsewhere on this site, that homage takes literal shape: an image of literature as “the ladder hanging close to the side of the schooner” borrows its ladder directly from Adrienne Rich’s “Diving into the Wreck.” Paying such debts openly is not separate from the writing life. It is close to the point of it, and it remains my quest.

Listen while you read

J. S. Bach, The Art of Fugue, Contrapunctus 8. Kimiko Ishizaka, piano. Public-domain recording, Internet Archive.

Scope of This Reading

What follows is a descriptive account of how Crossings is built—its sequence, its governing images, its habits of syntax and line. It asks how the poems work and does not rank them, and it notes where the craft falters as well as where it holds. Analysis that slides into praise stops being useful.

The collection under discussion is Crossings: Selected Poems—twenty poems, with dedication, acknowledgments, and introduction, published by Silver Current Press in August 2026; see the Crossings overview for the complete text. Quotations here follow the published text. Where this reading overlaps the collection’s own critical apparatus—The Poetics of Crossings, which reads the book’s figures and forms at length—the difference is one of scale: that study follows each poem at length; this one follows the shape of the whole.

Part One

Analysis

I. How the Sequence Is Built

The title holds the book together. It is not decoration. A crossing is a threshold event—a passage from one state to another—and the collection is arranged as a series of them: from childhood to knowledge, from health to illness, from presence to absence, from darkness toward light. The book opens in a domestic interior with “Copacetic,” a poem whose central gesture is a refusal (“I’m not hungry.” He pushed it away), and closes, before the epilogue, with “Moving Forward,” whose central gesture is an offering: “I place my arm under hers. / She stands, / kisses my forehead.” That is the arc of the book in miniature—from the plate pushed away to the hand extended.

Between those poles the sequence moves less by narrative than by pressure. Poems of family illness and decline (“Water,” “Last Supper,” “Fragility,” “The Teapot”) are set against poems of institutional life and vocation (“Longing,” “Session’s End,” “The Guard”), and against a small number of poems whose tone is deliberately lighter (“Simply Silly,” “Carol”). The lighter poems are not filler; they function as pressure valves, and their placement is one of the more deliberate things about the manuscript. A collection this concerned with grief needs air, and the sequencing supplies it at roughly the intervals a reader can bear.

The one structural risk is that the book’s emotional center of gravity sits in its middle third, where the illness poems cluster most densely. A reader arriving at “Water” has already absorbed a good deal; the poem is strong enough to survive the position, but the surrounding poems bear more weight than they otherwise would.

II. The Recurring Vocabulary

Four image systems govern the collection: hands, water, thresholds (doors, crosswalks, stairs), and light against darkness. They recur so consistently that the recurrence has to be a method, and the poet has said plainly that it is. The repetitions are purposeful: the same truths set down again in new hands, new voices, new incarnations. What looks like repetition is recurrence, and recurrence is the argument.

The hands are the collection’s most reliable instrument. They appear as evidence (“Your hands on my shoulders. / One moment, framed.” in “The Crosswalk”), as failed reach (“reaching for water / that will not rise” in “Water”), and finally as tenderness offered directly (“I place my arm under hers” in “Moving Forward”). Because the poet declines to gloss them, the hands gather meaning from where they appear, not from anything said about them—the reader learns what a cupped hand signifies in this book the way one learns a word from repeated context.

Water carries the heavier freight. In “Water” it is the thing the old man cannot reach; the poem’s catalog of a weathered body—“weathered face, / capillaries like tributaries / on dry land”—converts a body into a drought map, so that the closing phrase, “reaching for water / that will not rise,” lands as both literal thirst and something considerably larger. The figure is doing double service, and it does not announce the second service. That restraint is characteristic of the collection.

Light and darkness are the riskiest of the four, because the pairing is worn nearly smooth by use. The collection earns it in one place decisively—the closing line of “Dark City,” “I see you move from darkness into light”—where the phrase survives because the poem has spent its length refusing consolation, so the turn reads as report, not reassurance. Elsewhere the pairing is the collection’s most predictable move.

III. The Discipline of Restraint

The collection’s most consistent technical virtue is its refusal to explain. Its characteristic sentence is short, declarative, and slightly under-informed—it tells the reader what happened and stops before telling the reader what it meant. “Copacetic” is the clearest instance: a father’s four-word evasion, a four-word narrative clause, and no commentary. The poem trusts a reader to supply the grief.

This is harder than it looks. The temptation in poems of family illness is to secure the feeling with a closing statement; the poems here mostly decline. “Longing” is the exception worth noting because it declines in the opposite direction—the poem states its condition outright (“Mostly, I feel empty and small—/ a space between words or a tiny font”) and then rescues the statement with a figure precise enough to justify it: “The colon at the end of an unfinished thought.” A grammatical mark standing in for a life’s incompletion is the kind of image the poems find when they work best.

Where restraint slips, it slips into a final line that interprets the poem it concludes. There are perhaps three or four such endings in the manuscript. They are not failures of feeling; they are failures of trust.

IV. Formal Practice

The poems are free verse with a regular beat audible underneath, which the collection uses here and there without keeping it up. Three devices recur.

Syntactic suspension. “Water” moves through a sequence of descriptive fragments—face, capillaries, belly, ankles, skin—before the single verb of action arrives in its final movement: “He bends, / cupping his hands.” The poem holds the reader in description until the gesture finally comes, and the gesture fails.

Caesura as refusal. The collection favors two kinds of break—the line-ending dash that removes connective syntax (“The old man on the dock—”), and the hard stop after reported speech that declines elaboration. Both are deployed at moments of withheld tenderness, and the consistency suggests the device is tied to a recurring dramatic situation: the adult who will not explain.

Catalog and litany. “To Be” abandons connective syntax altogether for an asyndetic list—“the Wife of Bath’s scarlet stockings / poor Yorick’s skull / Dickinson’s sherry in the glass”—which levels literary monument and roadside debris (“a flattened sneaker on some road”) into identical syntactic weight. “Moving Forward,” at the other end, borrows the cadence of litany without adopting its apparatus. The two poems mark the collection’s formal outer limits: leveling on one side, blessing on the other.

Lineation is the element most uneven across the manuscript. The strongest poems break where breaking creates meaning; a handful break where the sentence happened to run out of room.

V. A Note on a Possible Illustrated Edition

The published edition of Crossings: Selected Poems is text-only. A separately planned illustrated edition, should it go forward, raises a real question of proportion, more than of taste. This is a collection whose method is withholding—it works by declining to interpret its own images. The danger is illustration that insists: a picture that fixes a single meaning where the poem has deliberately left the meaning open. Set carelessly, a picture of a cupped hand on the page facing “Water” would perform exactly the gloss the poem spent nine lines refusing to perform.

The productive path is the one the poems themselves take: suggestion over statement. Illustration that stays tonal—light, surface, weather, the grain of an interior—will extend the book’s atmosphere without closing its images. What the poems ask of a picture is a threshold, not a verdict: an image that invites and does not conclude. The safest course is to illustrate the thresholds, not the figures: doorways, crosswalks, stairwells, the surface of water, the room after someone has left it. Those images hold the collection together, and they can be drawn without being explained.

Four poems discussed elsewhere in this essay—“Longing,” “The Guard,” “To Be,” and “Simply Silly”—belong to the fuller manuscript rather than the published Selected Poems. Mulhern reserved them, along with the rest of the expanded sequence, for this future illustrated edition, where a larger page count and visual apparatus give him more room than the tighter, cohesion-driven published selection allowed. Readers curious about them can find the full text of every poem discussed in this essay on the Complete Collection page.

Those images are now being made. The illustrator, Mr. Cennamo, has begun painting the collection’s thresholds—a crosswalk, a stairwell, a lighthouse. For each poem, he has set down the essence as he perceived it, not to fix its meaning but to offer a threshold. His image is not the poem’s last word but an invitation: one way of seeing, held open so the reader may cross into a meaning of their own.

Painting in the style of Edward Hopper of a city street corner with a painted crosswalk and long raking shadows, a lone man waiting at the far curb
“The Crosswalk” · after Edward Hopper

Part Two

A Final Observation

The collection’s governing conviction is that nothing is finally lost—that what is laid down is taken up, that the same griefs and joys return in other hands, and that attention paid to a teapot or a cupped palm is a way of keeping what would otherwise go. That conviction is never argued in these poems. It is carried instead by the recurrence itself: the same images arriving again in new incarnations, each time slightly altered, none of them spent.

About the Author

James Mulhern has been published over 300 times in literary magazines, journals, and anthologies in the United States and around the world. His work has been recognized with numerous awards. In 2015, he was awarded a fully funded writing fellowship to Oxford University. That same year, a story was shortlisted for the Fish Short Story Prize. In 2017, he was nominated for a Pushcart Prize. His novel, Give Them Unquiet Dreams, is a Kirkus Reviews Best Book of 2019 and a 2019 Readers’ Favorite Bronze Medal winner. He was shortlisted for the Aesthetica Creative Writing Award 2020 for his poetry. Two of his novels were Finalists for the United Kingdom’s Wishing Shelf Book Awards. He is a professor and writer living in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, where he teaches The Art of Telling.

Read the Complete Collection The Poetics of Crossings Prosody Seminar What Is Laid Down Is Taken Up

Silver Current Press family: Silver Current Press · The 2601 Salon · For Program Partners · Mulhern Teaches English · The Gathering Room →